Literary Saloon

the literary
weblog at the
complete review

the weblog

about the saloon

support the site





the Literary Saloon on Kindle

to e-mail us:

literary weblogs:

  Arts Journal
  Books, Inq.
  Critical Mass
  Guardian Unlimited
  Jacket Copy
  The Millions
  NewPages Weblog
  Three Percent
  Typographical Era

  Papeles perdidos
  Rép. des livres

  Arts & Letters Daily
  Arts Beat/Books
  Brandywine Books
  Collected Miscellany
  Light Reading
  The Millions
  The Page
  ReadySteady Blog
  The Rumpus
  Two Words
  wood s lot

  See also: links page

saloon statistics

the Literary Saloon at the Complete Review
opinionated commentary on literary matters - from the complete review

The Literary Saloon Archive

11 - 20 December 2013

11 December: WLT's 75 Notable Translations 2013 | Publication date for Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki | The Butterfly - the radio play
12 December: Naguib Mahfouz Medal for Literature | Translation and context | Literature in ... Bulgaria | The Summer of Dead Toys review
13 December: Man Booker Prize judging panel | Dany Laferrière elected to Académie française | P.D.James on 'the golden age of crime' | The Conductor review
14 December: Medical analysis of the Bond-novels | Laureate for Irish fiction | Chinese literature in English
15 December: Translation in ... India | Profiles: Geoffrey Hill - Meja Mwangi
16 December: 21世纪年度最佳外国小说 | Lire's 20 best of 2013 | The Night Sessions review
17 December: Prizes: Joseph Conrad Prize - Albatros Literaturpreis | Amazon's 2013 bestsellers | Worst of the year list
18 December: Rentrée littéraire 2014 preview | 'Trade courtesy' in Iran | Politicians' books in ... Korea
19 December: More on French books in English | Dutch fiction and the BTBA
20 December: Palestinian literature | Russian literature abroad | THE 'Best books of 2013' | Genre fiction and the BTBA

go to weblog

return to main archive

20 December 2013 - Friday

Palestinian literature | Russian literature abroad
THE 'Best books of 2013' | Genre fiction and the BTBA

       Palestinian literature

       At Fakhri Saleh 'explores the effect that the loss of homeland has had on Palestinian literature and self-perception', in A Nation Crafted From Words -- a solid overview (though with a focus on past rather than present authors ...).

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Russian literature abroad

       The headline of Dmitry Bak's Russia beyond the Headlines article -- From Chekhov to Akunin, Russian literature is being condensed -- seems to have lost something in translation, but his lament -- "The bottom line is that the majesty of Russian literature has fallen from favor, or rather it has dissipated" -- comes across loud and clear.
       More defensive than usual for these variations on the familiar no-one-understands-us(-and-that's-why-they're-not-buying-our-books) article, Bak suggests:
Then there are authors who fare rather well in the country of export, namely Russia, but then flop in the import country. There are many of these, but they flop not because they are too Russian or too provincial, but for more indistinct, more sociological reasons. Much like a stock market index, interlinked with the subtle ups and down of the market.

The level of Russian literature is notably high, just as it always was, but it is extremely difficult or even impossible to transpose this into another context.
       Ah, those mysterious sociological reasons .....
       What it boils down to ?
The point there is that Russian literature is not conceited, it simply digs too deep for most ordinary people.
       Oh, bless them for taking themselves (and the products of the beloved motherland) so seriously.
       (That said, I agree that far too little contemporary Russian fiction makes it abroad -- and especially into English. But there are a lot of reasons for this, and suggesting Russian literature "digs too deep for most ordinary people" is not a good starting point to fix any of these.)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       THE 'Best books of 2013'

       I've been trying to keep the 'best books of the year lists' links to a minimum here -- I'm sure you come across your fill elsewhere -- but a few are worth pointing to. So also now the Times Higher Education Best books of 2013 -- 'The year's best reads for work and pleasure, chosen by scholars and senior figures in the sector', which offers a pretty interesting range.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Genre fiction and the BTBA

       Another blog post by me in my capacity as Best Translated Book Award judge at Three Percent, as I weigh in on The Genre Heap we deal with -- and wonder why so few genre titles (especially mysteries/thrillers) make it to the longlist stage and beyond.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

19 December 2013 - Thursday

More on French books in English | Dutch fiction and the BTBA

       More on French books in English

       Last week I discussed at some length Hugh Schofield's BBC News piece wondering Why don't French books sell abroad ?
       Now Laurence Marie, head of the book department at the US French Embassy, responds by turning the question, wondering Why Do French Books Sell Abroad ? She notes, as I did, that title-wise, translations from the French do very well in English -- relatively speaking (i.e. a lot more books are translated from French into English than from any other language -- even thought that's still a very small number of books ...). And she also provides some actual (or at least rough) numbers which are certainly of interest.
       First off, she mentions that US rights to Joël Dicker's The Truth About the Harry Quebert Affair went: "for about half a million dollars".
       She then offers some sales numbers (they seem to be US numbers, but it's not entirely clear and may in some cases include UK totals) -- including:        (Check out the others too -- interesting to see how these books have done, even if it is only a small sampling of titles.)
       Some of her arguments are kind of beside the point -- "French writers are frequently invited not only by American universities, but also by popular festivals" -- and I think she's a bit too bullish on French 'noir' conquering the English-speaking world. (Never mind that those two Didier Daeninckx novels from Melville House were reprints from yesteryear (Serpent's Tail brought them out in the early 1990s) -- but also: if you're going down that road, how can you forget the Jean-Patrick Manchette novels ? New York Review Books is bringing out another one next year ..... Meanwhile, something like Philippe Georget's Summertime, all the Cats are Bored is hardly very noir -- but if you're going to mention mysteries like that, why not the most successful of the French mystery authors, Fred Vargas ?)
       Still, it makes for a decent overview of much of what's coming into English from French nowadays.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Dutch fiction and the BTBA

       All of us Best Translated Book Award judges post prize-related entries at Three Percent, and my latest one is on the Dutch (and Flemish) titles in the running for the award -- not many titles but a pretty impressive selection.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

18 December 2013 - Wednesday

Rentrée littéraire 2014 preview | 'Trade courtesy' in Iran
Politicians' books in ... Korea

       Rentrée littéraire 2014 preview

       The French are already looking ahead to the first big flood of books in 2014: the fall rentrée littéraire is usually the period when the biggest titles come out, but the winter rentrée is also pretty significant, and in Le Figaro Mohammed Aissaoui looks ahead to Rentrée littéraire 2014: le grand bond en avant.
       Between 2 January and 27 February 547 works of fiction are coming out -- 352 French titles, and 195 translations.
       Aissaoui only introduces twenty-five of the titles, but some certainly sound of interest -- Paul Fournel offering "quinze nouvelles érotiques", a new Éric Chevillard. And there are some crowd-pleasers in the bunch, too: new works by David Foenkinos and Katherine Pancol, for example.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       'Trade courtesy' in Iran

       A couple of months ago I reviewed Robert Spoo's interesting work, Without Copyrights, which looked at the near-free-for-all that American copyright law made for with regard to foreign (both translated and first-published-abroad-in-English) works in the US well into the 20th century. Among the interesting developments was that of 'trade courtesy' among publishers, who often essentially deferred to whoever published first -- as if the work was copyright protected. Publishers went along with this because they also benefited, able to expect (more or less) that no one would compete with them in turn when they published a foreign work. The system wasn't iron-clad -- new entrants had clear incentives to cheat and bring out competing editions, for example -- but for the most part it worked surprisingly well.
       Iran, one of the few countries that still operates largely outside international copyright law, is in many ways in a similar situation as the United States was over a hundred years ago regarding the copyright protection for foreign (in their case basically: translated) work. This leads to competing translations being published -- often at nearly the same time: just last week I mentioned that two translations of Murakami Haruki's A Wild Sheep Chase were published in Iran within two weeks of one another.
       An extreme case is that of Khaled Hosseini’s recent novel, And the Mountains Echoed -- the second-bestselling title at in 2013. Apparently they figured it would be popular in Iran too -- and IBNA report that:
There are more that ten translations of the book in Iranian book market.
       Obviously, the 'trade courtesy' model did not apply here ....
       Aside from the fact that it's pretty impressive that they could get ten different translations to market so quickly -- well, this obviously isn't an ideal situation for anyone, from readers, who are presumably hard-pressed to guess which translation is the best, to the publishers who lose potential sales to competing editions. (I fear that, at least as far as royalties go, authors tend to be losers regardless of how their books are brought to the Iranian market: I assume that Mr. Hosseini and most others aren't collecting any royalties on any of these editions (though as in the US of yesteryear the author's blessing -- in the form of agreeing to 'authorized editions' -- can set translations apart and provide the author with a bit of cash-flow).)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Politicians' books in ... Korea

       The book-penned-by-a-politician (or at least published under his or her name ...) is a pre-election-year standard around the world, and in The Korea Times Kim Tong-hyung offers a look at the phenomenon in Korea, in considering the Use of useless literature.
       Among the reasons for publishing such a 'book':
"It would be illegal for a politician to throw an event aimed at galvanizing his supporters during a non-campaigning period. However, with book-launching ceremonies, they can create the same effect without violating the law," said an official from the National Election Commission, who didn't want to be named.
       It's not surprising that their primary purpose isn't literary:
It’s difficult to move these books, which are usually 200 to 300 pages of personal stories and essays and rarely convey intellectual arguments.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

17 December 2013 - Tuesday

Prizes: Joseph Conrad Prize - Albatros Literaturpreis
Amazon's 2013 bestsellers | Worst of the year list

       Prize: Joseph Conrad Prize

       I guess it makes sense that a Polish institution would award a prize named after a famous son -- though if that's Joseph Conrad I would have figured there was an English-language connection. Not so in the case of the biennial Nagroda literacka im. Josepha Conrada-Korzeniowskiego, awarded by the Polish Institute in Kiev -- which goes to a Ukrainian writer.
       They've announced that Tanja Maljartschuk (so at least the German transliteration of her name [updated: Tania Malyarchuk seems the going English transliteration -- and she had a story in the 2013 Best European Fiction anthology published by Dalkey Archive Press]) has won this year's prize, which comes with €3000 and a six-months stay in Poland. See also, for example, the Residenz Verlag foreign rights page of her latest book published in German -- to good notices.
       Previous winners of this prize include Serhiy Zhadan (2009) -- whose Depeche Mode Glagoslav brought out in English this year; see their publicity page, or get your copy at or
       Not nearly enough gets translated from the interesting Ukrainian literary scene, and if this prize helps as a stepping stone -- well, that's good.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Prize: Albatros Literaturpreis

       The biennial Internationaler Literaturpreis Albatros -- awarded by the Günter Grass Stiftung Bremen -- has announced its 2014 winners (yes, they'll only get to pick up the prize in April); not at the official site, last I checked, but see for example the report in Focus.
       This prize for any international work of literary fiction, poetry, or non-fiction, is notable for dividing the €40,000 pay-out between author (€25,000) and translator (€15,000).
       The prize goes to The Buddha in the Attic, by Julie Otsuka and her translator Katja Scholtz.

       (I haven't looked too hard, but I haven't learned why the prize is named after the bird -- in English, after all, an albatross isn't exactly the kind of prize any author wants hung around his neck. My guess is that the meaning they're going after is more the albatross of Baudelaire's eponymous poem, rather than Samuel Taylor Coleridge's Rime .....)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Amazon's 2013 bestsellers

       This barely seems worth a mention (though it seems to have gotten a lot of them), but, as the official press release has it, Amazon Announces Best-Selling Books of 2013.
       I do mention it because I am fascinated that they can get away without mentioning the actual number of books sold (data they actually have, after all, but which they're clearly unwilling to share) -- and because I can't recall ever seeing a bestseller list which includes the legal boilerplate:
This announcement contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
       The publishing/bookselling 'business' never fails to astound me.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Worst of the year list

       Steve Donoghue certainly seems to get through a lot of books, and while most end-of-the-year lists are a pretty boring lot he offers -- over a number of posts and days -- a variety of amusing variations on the theme at his Stevereads weblog. My favorite, of course, the: Worst Books of 2013: Fiction ! (something I would love to see from many more critics and readers).
       I've actually read three of these -- Woes of the True Policeman, How to Get Filthy Rich in Rising Asia, and Night Film. These I found more disappointing than truly bad (though I do agree that the Pessl is pretty darn bad) -- indeed, their inclusion suggests he's not trying nearly hard enough to seek out the truly dreadful.
       I've reviewed a few real clunkers this year, but one book easily rates as the worst of the lot: Rimbaud the Son by Pierre Michon (which is the only title at the complete review I have ever assigned a grade of "F" to, that's how much I hate this book). Amusingly enough, Donoghue recently reviewed it too, at the Quarterly Conversation -- favorably, too (yes, I'm afraid my opinion of that: "full flood of that Michonesque prose" is decidedly different).

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

16 December 2013 - Monday

21世纪年度最佳外国小说 | Lire's 20 best of 2013 | The Night Sessions review


       So the Chinese have an award for the 21世纪年度最佳外国小说 -- amounting to: the 'Best 21st Century Foreign Novel of the Year' -- and they've just announced this year's five winners:
  • Anne Gesthuysen's Wir sind doch Schwestern; see the KiWi foreign rights page (yes, rights sold in China -- obviously -- as well as Lithuania, the Netherlands, and Spain; US/UK ? not so much ...)

  • Daniil Granin's Мой лейтенант (which also won the Russian Большая книга ('Big Book') award (which, despite its silly name, is one of the big Russian literary prizes) in 2012. (Impressive side-note: Granin is ninety-four years old.)

  • Rodrigo Rey Rosa's Los sordos; see the Alfaguara publicity page (and, yes: available in Chinese translation; in English ... not so much ...)

  • Alessandro Piperno's Inseparabili -- which also took the 2012 Premio Strega, a leading Italian literary prize. (And again: want to read it in Chinese -- no problem. Want to read it in English -- tough luck.)

  • Olivier Adam's Les lisières; see also the Flammarion publicity page (English ...? never mind ...)
       At least other works by all these authors, save Gesthuysen, are available in English (see, for example reviews at the complete review of Adam's Cliffs or Rey Rosa's The African Shore)-- but interesting that the Chinese are so much more efficient in getting more recent books translated.
       (The idea of a prize for just 21st-century foreign fiction is interesting too -- the Best Translated Book Award (for which I am a judge) is open to any fiction that hasn't previously been translated; I haven't counted, but I suspect easily half the titles we're considering this year were written pre-2000.)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Lire's 20 best of 2013

       Best-of-the-year lists just aren't as popular outside the US/UK. One of the more notable ones (of the few ...) in France is Lire's Palmarès Lire: les 20 meilleurs livres de l'année 2013 -- which isn't strictly speaking a top twenty list -- which they announced a couple of weeks ago. They crown a book of the year -- Nobel Prize-favorite Svetlana Alexievich's latest (available in English ? ha !) -- but otherwise select a top book in any number of (well, nineteen) categories, including: best foreign novel (Mudwoman by Joyce Carol Oates), best first foreign novel (Yellow Birds by Kevin Powers), and so on.
       At least a lot of these are available in English -- because they were written in English. (Tellingly, none of the winners that weren't written in English is available in English -- though the Pierre Lemaitre (best French novel) will be sooner rather than later).)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       The Night Sessions review

       The most recent addition to the complete review is my review of Ken MacLeod's The Night Sessions.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

15 December 2013 - Sunday

Translation in ... India | Profiles: Geoffrey Hill - Meja Mwangi

       Translation in ... India

       In the Economic Times G.Seetharaman reports that Despite pitfalls, publishers bet on translated vernacular Indian literature.
       Good to hear -- and it's kind of surprising that it only now really seems to be taking off. After all:
"If you want to publish the best fiction in India it makes no sense not to publish translations," says R Sivapriya, managing editor, Penguin Books India. Since mid-2011, there has been a particular stress on English translations, she adds.
       But, as former diplomat Pavan K Varma notes:
Translation should have been a top priority in a country of so many languages but it was ignored.
       Interesting also the suggestion that:
Bengali had a head start over other languages in translations. "That was maybe because English language publishing was dominated by Bengalis.
       Now if we could just see more of this stuff outside India, too .....

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Profile: Geoffrey Hill

       In The Telegraph Sameer Rahim profiles the great poet, in Geoffrey Hill: poetry should be shocking and surprising.
       (Lots of his work is under review at the complete review; see our Geoffrey Hill page.)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Profile: Meja Mwangi

       In the Daily Nation Ciugu Mwagiru profiles Kenyan author Meja Mwangi, the reclusive writer with a mighty pen.
       I read a couple of his books that appeared in the African Writers Series back in the day, and he's continued to write steadily -- though the books have often been difficult to find abroad. (The observation that: "For some years now, he has been attracting the attention of American publishers" is also ... slightly misleading -- but at least the books do seem to be more readily available; get, for example, The Cockroach Dance at or
       A solid overview of his life and career -- including the interesting quote:
"My only mistake," he told an interviewer, "was that I didn’t use a pseudonym for my popular novels and use my own name for the rest. That way, I would have avoided all this criticism."

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

14 December 2013 - Saturday

Medical analysis of the Bond-novels | Laureate for Irish fiction
Chinese literature in English

       Medical analysis of the Bond-novels

       So among BMJ's ("formerly the British Medical Journal") Christmas 2013 research pieces is one which considers: Were James Bond's drinks shaken because of alcohol induced tremor ?
       The objective ?
To quantify James Bond's consumption of alcohol as detailed in the series of novels by Ian Fleming.
       The conclusion ?
James Bond's level of alcohol intake puts him at high risk of multiple alcohol related diseases and an early death. The level of functioning as displayed in the books is inconsistent with the physical, mental, and indeed sexual functioning expected from someone drinking this much alcohol. We advise an immediate referral for further assessment and treatment, a reduction in alcohol consumption to safe levels, and suspect that the famous catchphrase "shaken, not stirred" could be because of alcohol induced tremor affecting his hands.
       Hey, they seem to have taken it semi-seriously (though references to ..., and to a summary-article in the Daily Telegraph (complete with incorrect URL -- they're missing the "l" at the end of the .htm) of a New Scientist piece suggests: only so far), and the graphics are pretty cool.

       [Non-literary aside: another piece from this issue is an attempt:
To ascertain whether a name can influence a person's health, by assessing whether people with the surname "Brady" have an increased prevalence of bradycardia.
       Which has the rather disturbing and bizarre finding:
This finding shows a potential role for nominative determinism in health.
       Holy crap !
       (Cum grano salis, folks --- but still.)]

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Laureate for Irish fiction

       The (Irish) Arts Council has announced:
that it has established a new award which will honour an outstanding Irish fiction writer, and encourage the next generation of Irish fiction writers.
       It pays out €150,000 -- but that over three years, and with quite a bit of work attached:
The Laureate will have a three-year term. Over the period, he or she will teach creative writing to students at University College Dublin and New York University, will spend time developing his or her own work, and will participate in a number of major, public events and promotions.
       Still: presumably good exposure, and the money isn't bad.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Chinese literature in English

       As I've noted in recent weeks, Chinese literature may get a decent amount of attention in the US/UK, but there's still a bit of a disconnect between that and actual success -- or even just publication. I've noted that none of the 152-title strong IMPAC Dublin Literary Award longlist -- which includes 41 works in translation -- is a translation from the Chinese, and that the Best Translated Book Award apparently only has three works of fiction translated from the Chinese eligible for the prize covering 2013 publications (new translations of previously translated works and anthologies don't qualify, and works have to be published/distributed in the US). At Paper Republic they have a roll call of Chinese-to-English fiction and poetry translations (UK, US, and beyond) -- and it too is pretty pitiful .....
       At Asia Times Muhammad Cohen reviews two Lao She novels, in old translations re-issued by Penguin Classics (and hence hardly deserving of a place on the Paper Republic roll-call ...). The novels are interesting -- but the piece is mainly of interest for the Q&A with Penguin China's managing director Jo Lusby -- scroll down --, which is worth a look.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

13 December 2013 - Friday

Man Booker Prize judging panel | Dany Laferrière elected to Académie française
P.D.James on 'the golden age of crime' | The Conductor review

       Man Booker Prize judging panel

       The judging panel for the 2014 Man Booker Prize -- expanded from five to six judges (an even number, always dangerous for a decision-making body ...) -- has been announced.
       Three have previous Man Booker experience, three are first-timers. Apparently they bring: "with them a wide reading experience and knowledge of international literature".
       And the claim is:
The judges’ mission remains the same as in previous years: to select the finest fiction of the year.
       Unmentioned goes the fact that they're limited in the task by the extremely small number of titles they are allowed to consider, given the Man Booker's restrictive submission-allowances.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Dany Laferrière elected to Académie française

       Good to see there wasn't even much doubt about this one: Dany Laferrière was made an immortel, elected to take fauteuil 2 in the Académie française. He was elected handily, taking thirteen of twenty-three votes in the first round, good enough to sweep him into the seat. (The last vote they held, for fauteuil 21, didn't go nearly as well: three rounds and no winner, meaning they gave up and will have to try again later.)
       Haitian-Canadian author Laferrière well deserves the honor -- and several of his works are under review at the complete review:        And I'm looking forward to his latest, Journal d'un écrivain en pyjama.
       It's big news in France, of course, but they're also excited in Haiti (A great day for Haitian letters) and Canada (Novelist Dany Laferrière is first Canadian to be admitted to Académie française).

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       P.D.James on 'the golden age of crime'

       In The Spectator P.D.James remembers 'the gentlemanly world of Lord Peter Wimsey and Albert Campion' in writing about Who killed the golden age of crime ? (meaning, presumably 'the golden age of crime writing').
       Not really an exploration of that question, but interesting enough as an overview.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       The Conductor review

       The most recent addition to the complete review is my review of Jean Ferry's The Conductor and Other Tales, just out from Wakefield Press.
       The first full publication in English of this unusual collection -- and a lovely little (pocket-sized, hurrah !) volume.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

12 December 2013 - Thursday

Naguib Mahfouz Medal for Literature | Translation and context
Literature in ... Bulgaria | The Summer of Dead Toys review

       Naguib Mahfouz Medal for Literature

       As Mohammed Saad reports at aahram online, Syrian Writer Khaled Khalifa wins Naguib Mahfouz Medal for Literature, as his novel, لا سكاكين في مطابخ هذه المدينة, took this year's prize. Unfortunately, the Egyptians apparently wouldn't give him a visa, so he could not pick up the prize in person.
       No word yet at the official site, but see for example also the report at Arabic Literature (in English).
       Khalifa's In Praise of Hatred came out in the UK last year; a US edition is due in April, 2014; pre-order your copy from or get your copy from

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Translation and context

       A fascinating piece at by Stefan Weidner considers translations of classical Islamic literature (meaning actual Arabic and Persian literature, not religious-Islamic un-literature) in From the Emotional Orient to the Distortion of Islam.
       He suggests:
The Thousand and One Nights was a kind of Ossian. The tales owed the phenomenal success they enjoyed all over Europe to the time-bound style of the translation. If Galland had presented a translation of The Thousand and One Nights that was as sober, as fidčle, as the one published by Claudia Ott in 2004, we can be sure that The Thousand and One Nights would never have been noticed at all -- just as today the translation practices of Galland and the majority of his successors, about whom Jorge Luis Borges writes so vividly in his essay on 'The Translators of the Thousand and One Nights', are no longer to our taste. However, the question of which translation is better misses the point of what, above all, a translation has to offer.
       As the Ott-reference suggests, this piece was written in German and uses German-language literature/translations as the main reference point -- so too in suggesting:
Hafez is a poet who would also have been ideally suited to the Viennese avant-garde; his wordplay can best be compared in German with that of H.C.Artmann or Reinhard Priessnitz.
       (I'm guessing probably only a quarter of even my well-read readership is familiar with the works of Artmann and Priessnitz .....)
       As Weidner notes:
The compatibility of Oriental poetry in general and that of Hafez in particular with German literature between Sturm und Drang and late Romanticism is down to two factors, neither of which have anything to do with the original. One is the cultural deracination of this poetry. Because its original contexts are barely known, it is inevitably particularly open to interpretation. We can do with it and read into it what we will: it is unable to defend itself.
       A lot of interesting stuff here about translation -- much of which also applies to translation from other languages/cultures.
       I hope others pick up on the piece and comment.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Literature in ... Bulgaria

       At Radio Bulgaria Milka Dimitorva reports that there are More than 200 exhibitors at Sofia International Book Fair, which runs through the 15th.
       Among the odd/interesting titbits: the mention of Thrown into Nature-Milen Ruskov's: "Elevation which won the special Elias Canetti prize and took theatres by storm". A novel which takes theatres by storm ?
       Anyway, Ruskov's new novel sounds interesting -- Възвишение in the Bulgarian original; see the Жанет45 publicity page -- and I'm pleased to hear about this Elias Canetti Prize, with which I was unfamiliar.
       It's administered by the city of Ruse -- Canetti's birthplace -- and while it's nice they honor a hometown success in this way .... guys, he wrote in German. Anyway, see also the official site with the list of previous winners.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       The Summer of Dead Toys review

       The most recent addition to the complete review is my review of Antonio Hill's (except in his native Spain where he goes under the name 'Toni Hill') The Summer of Dead Toys.
       This is a serviceable thriller, but everything about it feels manufactured -- down to its international success. This apparently easily sold foreign rights far and wide in short order before or around publication. You can see how the specs -- plot outline, main characters -- and the author's translation background (the Wikipedia page even suggests his: "work as a translator was a great help in writing his first novel, as it exposed him to many books and diverse writing techniques") made this an easy sell, and yet all that is at the heart of the flaws of the book whose artificial construction creaks at every turn (even though Hill isn't half-bad as a writer). (Yes, all works of fiction are entirely artificial constructions, but the art is in not letting that show (or in showing it in a specific way): The Summer of Dead Toys reads like a padded blueprint .....)
       The international success (in terms of foreign rights sales) of this is Exhibit A (or Z -- there are so many) of what's wrong with publishing today -- specifically the publishing of international fiction. Sure, it's not terrible, and maybe even deserves to be available in English (thriller/mystery readers are an astonishingly forgiving lot, and will put up with a lot), but, even with its (very forced) series-potential, it's not worth paying very much for -- and I'm sure the foreign publishers paid through the nose for this. -- based not on actually reading the novel in its entirety but in swallowing the sales-pitch and maybe reading an excerpt (and, like I said, he certainly writes well enough, so any excerpt would look fine).
       (Astonishingly and embarrassingly, the German publisher of this is Suhrkamp, who clearly have entirely lost their way if they're betting on this sort of thing; yes, we've always pretended not to notice they publish Isabel Allende (mainly because they manage to make a mint off of her books, their literary reputation be damned), but this really is beneath and beyond them.)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

11 December 2013 - Wednesday

WLT's 75 Notable Translations 2013
Publication date for Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki
The Butterfly - the radio play

       WLT's 75 Notable Translations 2013

       At 75 titles, World Literature Today's Notable Translations 2013-list is certainly ... generous. (Recall that the Three Percent Translation Database finds a total of only 419 works of fiction and poetry translated into English and published in the US this year, a number that will probably increase as a few stragglers are added, but still .....)
       Overall, it's a pretty solid list, and not a bad place to start if you're looking for books in translation to read.
       That said, I do note that two titles on the list are, in fact, pretty damn old translations (re-issued this year -- but not new translations (unlike, for example, Sonallah Ibrahim's That Smell, which is at least a new translation of a previously translated work)): Forest of a Thousand Daemons by D.O.Fagunwa in Wole Soyinka's 1968 translation, and The Woman of Porto Pim by Antonio Tabucchi in Tim Parks' 1991 translation.

       There are also some notable omissions, including:
  • Antonio Muñoz Molina's In The Night of Time -- I haven't started this one yet, but come on: it's Edith Grossman, translating one of the leading contemporary Spanish authors; it's hard to imagine that doesn't make a top-75 cut ...

  • Jean-Marie Blas de Roblès' Where Tigers are at Home -- what is it about this book that absolutely everyone seems to continually overlook it ?

  • Mizumura Minae's A True Novel -- another big book from Other Press, which also strikes me as a very significant translation
       In addition, I think there's also a strong case to be made for at least an honorable mention of Chantal Wright's 'experimental translation' of Yoko Tawada's Portrait of a Tongue -- one of the more interesting examples of presenting translation to an audience.

       But, of course, the real disappointment is that they list 75 books and yet manage to fail to mention what is obviously the most notable translation-publication of the year, Giacomo Leopardi's Zibaldone. If you're talking 'notable' there's no way around this one, whether you're listing five or seventy-five titles.

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       Publication date for Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki

       As noted at The Millions, the English translation of Murakami Haruki's 色彩を持たない多崎つくると、彼の巡礼の年, Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and his Years of Pilgrimage (translated by Philip Gabriel) now has a US publication date: the Alfred A. Knopf publicity page says 12 August 2014 -- still a long wait, but you can already pre-order at
       The book is, of course already widely available elsewhere -- including in Spanish (Los años de peregrinación del chico sin color; see the Tusquets publicity page) and Polish (Bezbarwny Tsukuru Tazaki i lata jego pielgrzymstwa; see the Muza publicity page). (For the boy-is-it-a-small-and-bizarre-world files: the Polish translation is by Anna Zielińska-Elliott -- who teaches Japanese at Boston University (see her faculty page.)

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

       The Butterfly - the radio play

       James M. Cain's The Butterfly certainly isn't his best, and probably remains best-known now for that notorious film version (the Pia Zadora vehicle ... enough said), but BBC4 have been having a James M. Cain series, and they re-worked this one too. Their radio play-version is freely accessible at the site for a few more days (and less than an hour long).

(Posted by: M.A.Orthofer)    - permanent link -

previous entries (1 - 10 December 2013)

archive index

- return to top of the page -

© 2013 the complete review

the Complete Review
Main | the New | the Best | the Rest | Review Index | Links